Marinades are the unsung heroes of flavor. Typically, they contain an acid component, fat, salt, and various seasonings. This balance allows meat to become tender and flavorful. But when it comes to shrimp, you need to tread lightly with that acid. Too long in a citrus or vinegar marinade can lead to shrimp that’s not just bland but downright tough.
Rima Kleiner, a registered dietitian and food blogger, explains that while acids can enhance flavor, they can also negatively impact shrimp if left to marinate for too long. “Acid breaks down the proteins in shrimp, which can make the shrimp tougher if in vinegar or citrus juice for too long,” she notes. So, what’s happening on a molecular level? The acid initiates denaturation, changing the protein structure so that shrimp releases moisture and becomes chewy when cooked.
How to marinate shrimp so they don’t come out tough and chewy
Andrei Iakhniuk/Shutterstock
When shrimp marinates in acidic ingredients like citrus juice, it begins to “cook,” transforming into something akin to ceviche. To avoid an undesirable chewy texture, keep marinating time to 30 minutes or less in the refrigerator. This allows the acid to enhance flavor without compromising the moisture that is essential for perfect cooking.
If that feels like too much hassle, consider cooking shrimp without any acid. Simply using olive oil, herbs, and seasoning can create delicious results. However, a bright touch of citrus is often essential for that extra zing. Some chefs advocate for a dry brine using salt and baking soda as a “pre-marinade,” helping to both retain moisture and achieve that satisfying crispness.
A straightforward method is to directly cook shrimp in a citrus-based sauté sauce—think lemon or orange juice mixed with garlic and onion. Add the shrimp only once that sauce has developed flavor. This technique maximizes citrus impact while avoiding the risk of over-marinating. Keeping it simple can yield vibrant flavors without the risk of turning your shrimp into a chewy disappointment.
If you do choose to use citrus, a quick squeeze right at serving can elevate any dish—just remember the golden rule: do not let shrimp marinate in citrus for too long or you may end up with a ceviche instead.
