We are indeed in the golden era of gourmet burgers, where options extend far beyond the standard cheeseburger. While you may be tempted to experiment with decadent toppings like wagyu beef or unique aioli, let’s ground ourselves in the basics of seasoning. For an unbeatable burger, simplicity reigns supreme. Following the advice reminiscent of Michael Scott, “Keep it simple, stupid,” can lead to the best results in your kitchen.
According to burger expert Nathan Gerard of Pellet Head, the best seasoning for a burger patty consists solely of salt and pepper. Overcomplicating the mix can extract moisture, leading to a denser and less appealing texture. “You want the natural flavors of the beef to stand out,” Gerard asserts. This approach is echoed by renowned chef Bobby Flay, who also relies on these two classic ingredients, applying them only after forming the patties. This timing is pivotal for crafting a juicy burger that retains its texture.
Seasoning meat too early breaks down the proteins, resulting in a patty that can become rubbery and hard rather than succulent. While it might initially seem beneficial to have a firmer patty, the ultimate goal is a traditional, juicy cheeseburger experience.
Beyond Salt and Pepper
If you’re concerned that only using salt and pepper may leave your burgers a bit too plain for your guests’ palates, fear not! This minimalist approach offers a wonderful foundation for other flavor enhancements. As Nathan Gerard wisely points out, “You can always add seasonings after cooking or incorporate them into a homemade ketchup for an adventurous flair.”
If you decide to spice things up a bit while keeping the integrity of the beef intact, consider subtle additions. A splash of Worcestershire sauce, a hint of onion powder, or a sprinkle of smoked paprika can enhance the flavor without overwhelming the beef. These light touches can offer an elevating nudge to the meat’s inherent taste without masking it.
Dijon mustard or a drizzle of hot honey are also excellent options that can boost the burger’s flavor while ensuring a moist outcome. If you love mustard but want to avoid liquid ingredients, a smart move is to incorporate mustard powder, as recommended by chef Ina Garten—combining it with salt and pepper for a well-rounded flavor profile. This technique allows you to enjoy a double hit of mustard goodness without compromising the burger’s texture.
Image Source: Fuzull Hanum / Shutterstock
